Pennsylvania High School Alums on the FWAA’s All-American Teams

The Football Writers Association of America (FWAA) has been naming All-American football teams since 1944. I recently stumbled upon this guide featuring every team from that year through the 2019 selections. Naturally, I looked for any Pennsylvania connections and found our state well-represented throughout history. The FWAA selection is a long-standing All-American team, but is certainly not the only organization that chooses one.

  • Depending on whether you consider Eddie George an alumnus of a Pennsylvania high school, either 112 or 113 Keystone State grads have been named to the team from 1944-2019. George (Abington) spent the majority of his high school career at Fork Union Military Academy in Virginia. Not counted is defensive end Patrick Kerney, who was a native of Newtown but attended prep schools in both New Jersey and Connecticut.
  • No Pennsylvanians made the inaugural team in 1944. The first All-American named to the FWAA team was John Mastrangelo of Vandergrift High in 1945. A guard at Notre Dame, Mastrangelo made the second team in 1945 and the third team in 1946. These were some of the few years throughout the FWAA’s history where more than a first team were selected. Vandergrift is now part of Kiski Area.
  • After having seven total selections in the first four years of the team, Pennsylvania had 10 selections in 1948 alone. Other than that year, however, the state has produced a fairly consistent number of selections on an annual basis:All-Americans from Pennsylvania High Schools by Year
  • Two high schools have had four selections: New Castle and Bethlehem Liberty.
    • New Castle: Albert Tate (DT, Illinois – 1950), Bruce Clark (DL, Penn State – 1978 & 1979), and Malik Hooker (DB, Ohio State – 2016).
    • Bethlehem Liberty: Chuck Bednarik (C, Penn – 1947 & 1948), John “Bull” Schweder (G, Penn – 1949), and Mike Hartenstine (DL, Penn State – 1974).
  • In addition, six other schools – four of which are located in the WPIAL – have had three selections apiece.
    • Turtle Creek (now part of Woodland Hills): Leon Hart (E/T, Notre Dame – 1947, 1948 & 1949).
    • Northampton: Bob Novogratz (G, Army – 1958) and Dennis Onkotz (LB, Penn State – 1968 & 1969).
    • McKeesport: Bill Miller (E, Miami – 1960 & 1961) and Brandon Short (LB, Penn State – 1999).
    • Hopewell: Tony Dorsett (RB, Pitt – 1975 & 1976) and Paul Posluszny (LB, Penn State – 2005).
    • Penn Hills: Bill Fralic (OL, Pitt – 1983 & 1984) and Aaron Donald (DL, Pitt – 2013).
    • Wilkes-Barre Meyers (now part of Wilkes-Barre Area): Raghib “Rocket” Ismail (KR, Notre Dame – 1989 & 1990) and Qadry Ismail (KR, Syracuse – 1991).
  • Perhaps unsurprisingly, Penn State (30 selections) is the most common college for Pennsylvania high school alums named to the FWAA teams. Notre Dame (16) and Pitt (15) round out the top-three. After that, there is a large drop-off to fourth-place Army (5).
    • Penn (3 selections, all of which came from Bethlehem Liberty grads) is the only other Pennsylvania university represented.
    • Schools with just one Pennsylvania native named to the FWAA teams: Dartmouth, North Carolina, Illinois, Purdue, Tennessee, Kansas, Kentucky, Florida, Rutgers, Minnesota, Florida State, California, SMU, Tulsa, Virginia Tech and Wisconsin.
  • Thirty-five of the selections played on the offensive line. The next most popular position is running back, with 21 selections. There have been 12 linebackers chosen.
  • Thirteen players have been chosen for multiple FWAA All-American teams:
    • Arnold Galiffa (B, Army – 1948 & 1949)
    • Fralic
    • Miller
    • Clark
    • Bednarik
    • Onkotz
    • Mastrangelo
    • Johnny Lujack (B, Notre Dame – 1946 & 1947)
    • Keith Dorney (OL, Penn State – 1977 & 1978)
    • Hart
    • Raghib Ismail
    • Tom Skladany (P, Ohio State – 1974 & 1975)
    • Dorsett
  • For the full list of FWAA All-American selections, click here.

Fights and Forfeit: The 1928 Minersville-Shamokin Football Game

Note: This post was written by friend of the blog Shayne Schafer. Follow Shayne on Twitter for more Schuylkill County football history: @shayne_schafer. If you have an article you’d like to contribute to this site, send an email to pafbhistory@gmail.com.


On Saturday, October 28th, 1928, the Shamokin Greyhounds traveled to Minersville for an early-season clash. Minersville (2-1) had picked up shutout wins over St. Patrick’s and Pottstown. The Miners had multiple starters out after a rough Week 2 loss to Hazelton. Shamokin (0-2) hoped to take advantage and get back on the right track after two close losses to Mauch Chunk and Wyoming Seminary. Spirits were high and the Shamokin-Dispatch reported on the festive attitude of those supporters making the trek to Minersville.

M. A. A. Park
The setting for the matchup, M. A. A. Park was the home of Minersville High School athletics until 1935. Now Kings Village Plaza, Minersville Park was also the home of the Pottsville Maroons. | Photo courtesy of Ronald M. Coleman and Joseph E. Szeliga

Things didn’t go as planned; Shamokin forfeited with less than two minutes left in the game. The reports of this game would be wild, with stories of fans rushing the field, fights, cheating, dirty play, and inhospitable conditions created by Minersville and its supporters. Interestingly, depending on whose town’s newspaper you read, you would get a completely different account of what occurred.

Continue reading “Fights and Forfeit: The 1928 Minersville-Shamokin Football Game”

The Best Helmet in Pennsylvania High School Football: State Tournament Preview

Over the past couple of weeks, 563 teams have battled through 198 polls to determine who has the best helmet in Pennsylvania high school football. Now – following more than 72,000 votes – only 12 remain. It’s now time for the state tournament to decide who has bragging rights over the rest of the state.

How It’ll Work:

Instead of getting into the messy business of giving byes for a 12-team bracket, @thesteelersnat, @END2008 and I chose to have the state tournament decided via four regions of three teams apiece. The district champions will be grouped roughly by geography into the following pods:

Western PA Pod

  • Maplewood (D10 Champ)
  • Albert Gallatin (D7 Champ)
  • Carrick (D8 Champ)

Central PA Pod

  • St. Marys (D9 Champ)
  • Bishop Guilfoyle (D6 Champ)
  • Conemaugh Township (D5 Champ)

Northeastern PA Pod

  • Williamsport (D4 Champ)
  • Wyoming Area (D2 Champ)
  • East Stroudsburg South (D11 Champ)

Southeastern PA Pod

  • Marple Newtown (D1 Champ)
  • Wilson West Lawn (D3 Champ)
  • St. Joseph’s Prep (D12 Champ)

The Western and Central pods will be posted Saturday and the Northeastern and Southeastern pods will be posted Sunday. On Tuesday, the Western/Central semifinal and the Northeastern/Southeastern semifinal will be posted. Finally, the state championship poll will be posted Thursday and will be the only poll to remain open for 48 hours instead of 24.

I reached out via Twitter to each of the district champions to get a little more insight to their helmet design and its story. Let’s meet the contenders:

WESTERN PA POD

Maplewood

The Helmet

District 10 Champion Helmet

Helmet History (from the PA High School Helmet Project)

How They Got Here

  • Round 1: earned 44.5% of the vote, beating out Farrell and Sharpsville
  • District 10 Semis: earned 44.2%, beating out Fairview, Slippery Rock & Franklin
  • District 10 Final: earned 52.3%, beating out Grove City and Kennedy Catholic

The Story Behind the Helmet

From Head Coach Bryan Borkovich, who said each helmet takes 10-15 minutes to stripe:

Albert Gallatin

The Helmet

District 7 Champion Helmet

Helmet History (from the PA High School Helmet Project)

 They Got Here

  • Round 1: earned 46.2%, beating out Bentworth, Apollo-Ridge & Beth-Center
  • District 7 Quarterfinals: earned 41.8%, beating out Beaver Area and Avonworth
  • District 7 Semifinals: earned 42.3%, beating out Belle Vernon and Canon-McMillan
  • District 7 Final: earned 38.8%, beating out Pine-Richland and Woodland Hills

The Story Behind the Helmet

From Head Coach Drew Dindl:

Carrick

The Helmet

District 8 Champion Helmet

Helmet History (from the PA High School Helmet Project)

How They Got Here

  • District 8 Semifinals: earned 58.2%, beating out Allderdice and Westinghouse
  • District 8 Final: earned 51.8%, beating Brashear

CENTRAL PA POD

St. Marys

The Helmet

District 9 Champion Helmet (1)

Helmet History (from the PA High School Helmet Project)

How They Got Here

  • District 9 First Round: earned 61.1%, beating out Brockway, Curwensville & Moniteau
  • District 9 Semifinals: earned 40.7%, beating out Bradford and Brookville
  • District 9 Final: earned 51.6%, beating Cameron County

The Story Behind the Helmet

From Head Coach Chris Dworek:

Our helmet design was an idea from one of our coaches, Coach Mike Kunes.  He’s from St. Marys, played for them and has coached for them for a while now.  He’s been using that logo for the last few years on other, small things.  [The helmet has an] anchor chain down the middle (the players came up with that idea) and the other side of the helmet (it’s the players number which is a tribute to some old St. Marys helmets back in the day).  They’re pretty sharp.  The kids liked the entire helmet look and voted on it last Spring.  Some of the Brookville guys and my guys have become friends and each group has commented about how sweet each schools’ helmets look.

Coach Kunes also designed the Cameron County helmet, which means he is the creator of both finalists for District 9’s best helmet.

Bishop Guilfoyle

The Helmet

District 6 Champion Helmet

Helmet History (from the PA High School Helmet Project)

How They Got Here

  • District 6 First Round: earned 46.3%, beating out Glendale, Penn Cambria & West Branch
  • District 6 Semifinals: earned 31.3%, beating out Forest Hills, Johnstown & Hollidaysburg
  • District 6 Final: earned 38.1%, beating out Richland and State College

The Story Behind the Helmet

From the team’s Twitter account:

Conemaugh Township

The Helmet

District 5 Champion Helmet

Helmet History (from the PA High School Helmet Project)

How They Got Here

  • District 5 Semifinals: earned 74.5%, beating out Bedford, North Star & Somerset
  • District 5 Final: earned 65.3%, beating out Berlin-Brothersvalley and Meyersdale

The Story Behind the Helmet

From Conemaugh Township coach Wayne Adams:

Adams said that the decals are put on each year by Sportsman’s Sporting Goods in Johnstown and that parts of the helmet assembly must be removed and then reattached to add the design.

NORTHEASTERN PA POD

Williamsport

The Helmet

District 4 Champion Helmet

Williamsport has the chance to pull off a pretty remarkable feat. Last summer, I ran a similar tournament that named the Millionaires as the best nickname in the state. For that tournament, I removed duplicate nicknames (Tigers, Lions, etc.) and only included unique nicknames, which totaled a little over 100. If Williamsport manages to win the helmet bracket, they would take the crown over 562 competitors.

Helmet History (from the PA High School Helmet Project)

How They Got Here

  • District 4 First Round: earned 36.2%, beating out Central Columbia, Midd-West & Selinsgrove
  • District 4 Semifinals: earned 52.9%, beating out Loyalsock Township and Shamokin
  • District 4 Final: earned 42.0%, beating out Lewisburg and Danville

The Story Behind the Helmet

From Assistant Coach Keith McCabe:

The logo (top hat, cane, gloves, carnation) was designed back in the early 1960s (1961-63 era) by Thomas Mikan. Thomas was a student in the sign-painting program at Williamsport Technical Institute, predecessor of Pennsylvania College of Technology. As you may know the in the late 1800s, Williamsport had more Millionaires per Capita than any other city in the world, and was known as the “Lumber Capital of the World.” Many became rich due to trade and Susquehanna River. To this day, there still sits “Millionaires Row” on W fourth St, with all the Victorian homes that the millionaires lived in.

Helmet Facts:

  • We did not display the Top Hat & Cane logo on the helmet until 2013. Prior to that our helmets were blank, or used various “W’s” over the years. Most frequently the Wisconsin “W”.
  • The CURRENT helmet design was debuted in 2016. Coach Crews second season with the team. For the first time in our school history we changed our helmet color to black. Our school colors are Cherry & White and remained our helmet colors for all the years prior. Black has been a secondary color but goes with the black top hat appeal in our opinion. The diamond stripes running down the center of the helmet, pay homage to our old stadium (prior to turf) that displayed cherry & White Diamond endzones, along with yardage numbers.

Wyoming Area

The Helmet

District 2 Champion Helmet (1)

Helmet History (from the PA High School Helmet Project)

How They Got Here

  • District 2 First Round: earned 32.4%, beating out Delaware Valley, Lake-Lehman & Scranton
  • District 2 Semifinals: earned 44.3%, beating out Crestwood and Dallas
  • District 2 Final: earned 46.4%, beating out Old Forge and Lakeland

The Story Behind the Helmet

From Wyoming Area broadcast team member Frank D. (@wascoreboard):

The Warrior helmet has undergone many designs and redesigns in the fifty plus years of the program. The current version is based off of the Wyoming Area School seal and is a redesign of the version used in the late 70s and early 80s. It was developed by PA State Hall of Fame Coach Paul Marranca and current Asst Head Coach Mike Fanti. Given our recent history; it’s likely to be around for a while.

As far as interesting things about the helmet…the program started in 1967 with what was essentially a plain gold helmet…..at the annual Unico games each summer; the kids wear stickers from teams on their side of the Susquehanna River on their own helmets for the contest. The Warrior sticker is always one of the most sought after.

Wyoming Area’s helmet features a depiction of the Wyoming Monument, built to memorialize the victims of the Wyoming Massacre in the late 1700s.

East Stroudsburg South

The Helmet

District 11 Champion Helmet (1)

Helmet History (from the PA High School Helmet Project)

How They Got Here

  • District 11 First Round: earned 33.8%, beating out Northampton, Pocono Mountain West & Williams Valley
  • District 11 Semifinals: earned 34.8%, beating out Pottsville, Emmaus & Notre Dame
  • District 11 Final: earned 36.8%, beating out Nazareth and Shenandoah Valley

The Story Behind the Helmet

From Head Coach Matt Walters:

Prior to Ed Christian becoming head coach at East Stroudsburg, the Cavalier helmet was purple and the logo was a block “E”. In 1981, Ed Christian replaced Dick Merring as head coach. Ed and his staff took a trip down to the University of North Carolina for a coaches clinic, and liked the look of interlocking letters on the Tarheels helmet. The interlocking ES was put onto the purple helmet that fall and has been on Cavalier helmets ever since.

In 2004, Head Coach Ed Christian, assistant coach Tony Rose, and longtime program friend Ted Monica added the Cavalier swords to the interlocking ES logo, inspired by the University of Virginia swords under their “V” logo. For the past 16 seasons, the logo and purple helmet have remained the same. There have been a few additions and deletions of different stripes and add-ons, but the tradition of the interlocking ES with swords (with a little inspiration from two college football programs) have been a staple of East Stroudsburg football.

*As long as I’m here at East Stroudsburg South, that Logo and helmet will never change! Who am I to change the tradition and history of our high school?*

SOUTHEASTERN PA POD

Marple Newtown

The Helmet

District 1 Champion Helmet MN

Helmet History (from the PA High School Helmet Project)

How They Got Here

  • District 1 First Round: earned 41.3%, beating out Chichester, Pottstown & West Chester Henderson
  • District 1 Quarterfinals: earned 48.8%, beating out Coatesville and Radnor
  • District 1 Semifinals: earned 43.2%, beating out Pope John Paul II and Neshaminy
  • District 1 Final: earned 51.5%, beating Perkiomen Valley

The Story Behind the Helmet

From the Marple Newtown Athletics Twitter account (@MNAthletics):

The Tiger design is the district Tiger that we all use. We started wearing this helmet in 2015.

Before that was a black helmet with an orange paw. Before that (basically the 90’s) black helmet with Tigers in orange written in cursive. Before that (some of 80’s) black helmet with Tigers in white cursive. Before that we did have a orange helmet with MN in black on it. Legendary Coach Jim Smith was famous for coming up with cool designs. He coached from 1987-1997 and he was also the AD for a number of years.

Wilson (West Lawn)

The Helmet

District-3 Champion Helmet

Helmet History (from the PA High School Helmet Project)

How They Got Here

  • District 3 First Round: earned 54.1%, beating out Conrad Weiser, Hempfield (3) & Palmyra
  • District 3 Quarterfinals: earned 46.6%, beating out Northern York, Harrisburg & Wyomissing
  • District 3 Semifinals: earned 46.9%, beating out Warwick and Daniel Boone
  • District 3 Final: earned 50.6%, beating Red Lion

The Story Behind the Helmet

From Coach Joe Mays:

I know the exact same helmet design was used from 2000-2007 (white helmet, red facemask, single red stripe, red bulldog) and 2008-2015 (same as 2000-2007 but white facemask), and 2016-2018 (same as 2008-2015 but the red was now chrome red – a big deal for Dahms.

St. Joseph’s Prep

The Helmet

District 12 Champion Helmet

Helmet History (from the PA High School Helmet Project)

How They Got Here

  • District 12 First Round: earned 65.0%, beating out Academy of Palumbo, Father Judge & Neumann-Goretti
  • District 12 Semifinals: earned 50.0%, beating out Mastery North, Northeast & Archbishop Ryan
  • District 12 Final: earned 53.2%, beating out Imhotep Charter and LaSalle

So there you have it – all twelve finalists. The polls may not open until Saturday, but let the debate begin now!

The “Best Helmet in Pennsylvania High School Football” Tournament

Last summer, I found myself with a little down-time and chose to spend it by putting up a bunch of Twitter polls to find the coolest high school football nickname in Pennsylvania. I limited it to unique nicknames (so no Tigers, Lions, etc.), but it still meant whittling down a list of about 115 schools to find our champion (which ended up being the Williamsport Millionaires).

Well, thanks to the current state we all find ourselves in, down-time has once again become more prevalent. I had an idea yesterday and, with an enormous amount of help from the awesome @thesteelersnat and @END2008, it’s coming to life. This will be another tournament because we need some competition in our lives right now and Twitter polls are easy to run. But this will be even bigger than the nickname tournament from last summer. Much bigger.

The goal here is to find the best high school football helmet in Pennsylvania. It is up to you to determine what qualifies as “best.” Coolest looking? A classic look from a traditional power? Your alma mater’s helmet? Go for it – any reason you can come up with is good enough for a vote. Unlike the nickname tournament, however, we won’t be limiting choices to a certain number of entries. Every helmet of a current PIAA program is eligible to win and will be included in the tournament. That’s 563 helmets from all 12 districts (sorry, Inter-Ac and other independent schools).

All-Helmets

Here’s How It’ll Work:

  1. @thesteelersnat, @END2008 and I spent much of today building the brackets and graphics that will be used for voting.
  2. I will be sending out a graphic that shows every helmet in a particular district. In the attached thread below that graphic, I’ll post all of the Twitter polls involving teams from that district. So, for example, I’ll send out a tweet with @END2008’s District 1 helmet graphic. Threaded underneath that tweet will be the polls that will include all District 1 teams. If you need to refer to the graphic for a helmet you haven’t seen, just scroll up to the top of the thread.
  3. Districts have been divided into 3 or 4 team “pods” to simplify voting. Some districts are very big and others only contain a few schools; the WPIAL has 120 programs while District 8 only has 6. The polls will ask you to vote for your favorite out of the three or four choices for that pod. After 24 hours, the helmet with the highest vote percentage will move on to the next round until a “District Champion” has been named.
    1. A few important notes: We made a couple of executive decisions regarding the placement of certain teams.
      1. Butler (while still a member of the WPIAL in all other sports) will compete out of District 10, which is where it will be competing in football starting this fall. This was done to simplify the bracketing process for the WPIAL, which is enormous.
      2. Ligonier Valley, however, WILL compete through the WPIAL because the school is moving all sports there starting this fall. Think of it as LV’s first chance to win a WPIAL title – and they aren’t even in the district yet!
      3. We didn’t have an image of the new Central Clarion co-op team from District 9, so you’ll see the Clarion HS helmet instead. Apologies to Clarion-Limestone and North Clarion fans, but it’s the best we could do.
      4. Finally, we were unsure whether Vaux or Strawberry Mansion should have their helmet used in their proposed co-op for the fall, so we chose Strawberry Mansion because they’ve had an established program already.
  4. At the end, all 12 District Champions will be put into a Final Bracket to decide the best overall helmet in the state.

Sound simple enough? This is of course meant to be a fun way to pass the time in this sports-less abyss we find ourselves in currently. Make it competitive, share it and enjoy it. This will involve a lot of Twitter polls being sent out by me, but I’ll try to batch them in a way that isn’t obnoxious. However, it’s tough to do a project of this scale without it seeming overwhelming. If you don’t want to participate or see the polls, just skim past my tweets for the next week or two – you won’t hurt my feelings.

I’m planning to begin posting polls tomorrow (Thursday, April 2) around noon. Let’s get to votin’, everyone.

Pennsylvania Football Recruiting History, 2000-2020

Recruiting has come a really long way over the past 21 years. In 2000, the website Scout.com ranked the top high school recruits in Pennsylvania – well, at least the top four recruits in the state. Before that, die-hards need to subscribe to newsletters or (if you can believe it) call recruiting hotlines for the latest information. Today, you can find recruiting profiles for tons of players all the way through the class of 2024. I don’t follow recruiting closely because it has never really engaged me. However, there’s no denying the widespread popularity of following one’s favorite college program’s recruiting efforts or the importance the process can play for the athletes themselves.

What I wanted to do was find if there were any trends, notable statistics or other interesting facts in the world of recruiting as it pertains to Pennsylvania football players. The 2000 class is the first one that can be found in the 247Sports archives today and the 2020 class signed early last month. During that time period, 1,471 players have been included in the 247Sports rankings of top players in Pennsylvania. Of those, I’ve found at least eight chose to play another sport in college. That leaves us with 1,463 graduates of Pennsylvania high schools who signed letters-of-intent to play football following their senior year. A small handful of those players went to prep school and then reappeared in the rankings the following year, but this is a negligible amount.

Now, before we get too far, I want to lay out a few basic points:

  • I chose to use the 247Sports Composite rankings for each year because it covers the entire span of 2000-present. As I said earlier, I’m not a recruiting nut, but I do know that 247Sports is widely held as the best site in the business, so that made the decision even easier. 247Sports was founded in 2010 and bought Scout.com in 2017, allowing them to display the backdated rankings online.
  • That being said, rating and evaluating thousands of athletes does leave room for errors and I’ve found several on the 247Sports pages. I’ve fixed all of the ones that I’ve found, but more certainly remain. If you find an error, please let me know. The most common errors are misidentified high schools, typos in player names and duplicating a player so he appears twice in the same year’s rankings.
  • The data I gathered contains where the player signed, not necessarily where he played or where he ended up spending his whole career. For example, you’ll see that in 2006 LeSean McCoy is listed as signing with Miami; he later chose to attend prep school and enrolled at Pitt the following year.
  • Other players choose to attend prep schools or junior colleges before signing day. Because my focus was on which four-year colleges players signed with, I chose not to include the name of the prep school or junior college the player went with; this would have added a significant amount of time to an already lengthy research project. Instead, you’ll just see “Prep School” or “JUCO” as where that player signed.
  • Despite researching for quite a while, there are still 12 players whose whereabouts I couldn’t find. These players are listed with a question mark in the “Signed With…” column. If you can fill me in, let me know. I also found evidence of four additional players not playing football or another sport collegiately after high school. Their signing column says “none.”
  • Finally, I shouldn’t have to say this, but I will: Nothing written in this post is meant to be disparaging in any way. There are tons of athletes across the state who go on to play college football who exceed their rankings and there are some who aren’t able to live up to them. Getting a D1 offer is not the end all, be all for an athlete and nothing in this post suggests that other levels of football are inferior – I just don’t have complete data for FCS, DII, DIII, etc.

The entire list of recruits can be found here. Let’s get started.

Recruits by Year

The total number of Pennsylvania football players ranked by 247Sports has varied quite a bit over the years, peaking at a high of 111 in 2012. The average is about 70 athletes per year:

Ranked Pennsylvania High School Football Players by YearPerhaps more interesting than the total number of ranked recruits each year is the number of recruits by star rating. Every fan wants their college team to scoop up as many “blue chip” recruits as possible, but there has been a sentiment in some recent years that Pennsylvania is not producing these players in the volume it used to. I wanted to see if the rates of four-and-five star recruits from Pennsylvania had changed over time:

5-Star and 4-Star Players from Pennsylvania by Year

As you can see, Pennsylvania has produced a pretty stable number of blue-chip football players each year for the past two-plus decades. There has been a dip in the past two recruiting classes, but it’s too soon to tell if that will develop into a long-term trend. I was surprised to see how consistent the data was for this question, particularly from 2006-2018. Overall, Pennsylvania has produced a total of 22 five-stars and 170 four-stars since 2000. The five-stars are listed below:

Player School Year
Jeff Smoker Manheim Central 2000
Kevin Jones Cardinal O’Hara 2001
Cecil Howard McKeesport 2001
Marlin Jackson Sharon 2001
Dan Connor Strath Haven 2004
Anthony Morelli Penn Hills 2004
Chad Henne Wilson (West Lawn) 2004
Justin King Gateway 2005
Callahan Bright Harriton 2005
Marques Slocum West Catholic 2005
LeSean McCoy Bishop McDevitt 2006
Terrelle Pryor Jeannette 2008
Jonathan Baldwin Aliquippa 2008
Dorian Bell Gateway 2009
Sharrif Floyd George Washington 2010
Noah Spence Bishop McDevitt 2012
Rushel Shell Hopewell 2012
Robert Foster Central Valley 2013
Miles Sanders Woodland Hills 2016
D’Andre Swift St. Joseph’s Prep 2017
Micah Parsons Harrisburg 2018
Julian Fleming Southern Columbia 2020

There is a final way we can evaluate the quality of each class. By averaging the national rank of each year’s top five recruits in the state, we can get a more detailed look at how Pennsylvania classes stack up to the rest of the country on a year-by-year basis. Selecting the top five is certainly somewhat arbitrary, but it also gives an idea of how strong that year’s elite recruits are (lower is better in this chart):

Average Rank vs. Year

Of course, it’s important to remember that all recruiting rankings are based largely on subjective opinions and some states may be overrated or underrated based on the amount of talent they have historically produced. However, this method suggests that while Pennsylvania’s rate of producing blue-chip players has been fairly stable, the average ranking of those blue chips has been lower on average in recent years. This method also highlighted the fact that since 2000, Pennsylvania has produced just six players ranked in the top ten nationally:

  1. Kevin Jones, RB, Cardinal O’Hara – the state’s only top-ranked player (2001)
  2. Terrelle Pryor, QB, Jeannette – #2 (2008)
  3. Sharrif Floyd, DL, George Washington – #6 (2010)
  4. Noah Spence, DL, Bishop McDevitt – #5 (2012)
  5. Micah Parsons, DL, Harrisburg – #5 (2018)
  6. Julian Fleming, WR, Southern Columbia – #3 (2020)

The chart shows evidence of the cyclical nature of talent production; you can clearly see ups and downs from year-to-year. But the trend line that I added is telling, too – and it’s not headed in the direction we’d all hope it would. Again, this is all just based on signing day rankings and lots of players over-perform low ratings (more on them later).

Recruits by High School

Twelve schools in Pennsylvania have produced at least 20 ranked recruits from 2000-2020. The chart shown below clipped some of the school names; Pittsburgh Central Catholic is first, Bishop McDevitt is fourth, Valley Forge Military Academy is ninth and Archbishop Wood is 11th. Only two schools statewide have produced two five-star players:

  • Gateway (Justin King and Dorian Bell)
  • Bishop McDevitt (LeSean McCoy and Noah Spence)

Interestingly, despite leading the state in ranked players (41), Pittsburgh Central Catholic has never had a five-star recruit according to 247Sports. Central Valley, on the other hand, has had only two ranked recruits in its brief history, but they were a five-star (Robert Foster) and a four-star (Jordan Whitehead). Both players were rated as the best in Pennsylvania during their respective senior seasons.

Schools with the Most Ranked Recruits, 2000-2020

In all, 346 different high schools have had a player ranked by 247Sports since 2000, including defunct programs like Schenley, Duquesne, Cardinal Dougherty, Delaware Valley Charter, Strong Vincent and all three former Wilkes-Barre high schools, among others.

When we narrow our focus to five-star and four-star recruits, the graph changes a bit:

Blue Chip Recruits by School, 2000-2020

(Again, the chart clipped some names. Bishop McDevitt is 2nd, North Allegheny is 6th, Pittsburgh Central Catholic is 7th, Archbishop Wood is 8th, Cardinal O’Hara is 9th, Downingtown East is 10th, and Thomas Jefferson is 14th. I apologize for my lack of technical skills.)

Not surprisingly, this chart (and the one before it) double as a roll call for blue-blood programs in the state. Perhaps the most notable omission is St. Joe’s Prep, which just missed the cutoff by having three blue chips.

Recruits by College Choice

Over the past two decades, coaches from the three FBS programs in Pennsylvania have made concerted efforts – and attached slogans – to keeping the best in-state recruits within the state’s borders. From “Dominate the State” to “building a wall around western Pennsylvania,” coaches at Penn State, Pitt and Temple have worked hard to keep local talent, well, local. If you’re a fan of one of the three in-state FBS programs, you may want to skip over this next table; it’s a little tough to look at. The college choices of the top-five recruits in Pennsylvania since 2000:

Screen Shot 2020-03-23 at 8.50.50 PM

With Pennsylvania’s long history of producing talent, it’s no surprise to see a variety of different programs fill this chart; after all, any program worth its salt will recruit nationally and pursue the best players no matter where they are. But it’s still a little disconcerting for fans of our state’s three programs to see an invasion of out-of-state teams in this chart, especially in the column listing the top recruit each year. Penn State has snagged the state’s top recruit just four times in 21 recruiting classes (the same as Ohio State). Pitt has done it twice and Temple has only gotten one top-five player ever (Karamo Dioubate in 2016).

As it does in nearly every state, Notre Dame has made inroads during this timeframe, particularly since 2017. Michigan was a strong threat in the early 2000s and various southern schools have garnered commitments over the years. Top-ranked recruits aside, Penn State has held its ground pretty well in the James Franklin era, managing to grab the 2nd-through-5th ranked player pretty frequently. Pat Narduzzi has had a tougher time at Pitt, receiving commitments from four top-five recruits since taking over in 2015.

A total of 136 different collegiate programs have gotten commitments from ranked Pennsylvania recruits since 2000. The top ten are:

SCHOOL RECRUITS
Pittsburgh 161
Penn State 119
Temple 119
West Virginia 60
Akron 55
Connecticut 45
Syracuse 40
Rutgers 39
Toledo 34
Buffalo 31

While it’s no surprise to see the three in-state programs at the top of the list, Pitt leads all college programs by a wide margin. In fact, 11% of all ranked Pennsylvania recruits from 2000-2020 committed to Pitt. West Virginia is the most common out-of-state destination, which shouldn’t be surprising. What did surprise me was the fact that Rutgers ranked just 8th by this measure. I had assumed it would be in the top five based on geographic location and the fact that its home state gets raided for talent by out-of-state programs on an annual basis.

Pennsylvania’s 22 five-star recruits have gone to Penn State five times, Ohio State four times, Michigan three times and Pitt twice. Schools that nabbed one five-star apiece are Syracuse, Michigan State, Virginia Tech, Florida, Miami, Florida State, Alabama and Georgia. For four-stars, Penn State has gotten 52 while Pitt has 27. Notre Dame has signed 18 and Michigan got 11.

When we narrow our focus to the in-state universities, we can see how they stack up against one another in terms of getting Pennsylvania recruits. Let’s look at another graph!

Commitments by Star Rating, 2000-2020 (1)

Of Pitt’s 161 in-state commits, 112 of them are three-stars. Penn State and Temple each have a total of 119 in-state commitments during the same period. Penn State is evenly balanced between three-stars and four-stars, while Temple’s commits historically have mostly been rated as two-stars or, less frequently, three-stars. It’s important to note that the program Temple is today is a far cry from the program it was in the early 2000s, so the long-term nature of this study doesn’t clearly reflect the strides Temple has made in the past several years.

Nationally, there are 130 FBS programs and 39 have failed to sign a Pennsylvania recruit over the past 21 years. You likely won’t be surprised by many schools on this list; many of them are geographically distant and others have been Division I programs for only a short time. Remember, this doesn’t mean these schools have zero Pennsylvanians on their rosters – they just haven’t signed any state-ranked ones out of high school since 2000. Think of this list as the bingo card we can use for future recruiting classes:

Appalachian State Louisiana-Lafayette Oregon State Tulsa
Arkansas Louisiana-Monroe Rice UNLV
Arkansas State Louisiana Tech San Jose State UTSA
Auburn Memphis SMU Utah
Boise State Middle Tennessee South Alabama Utah State
California Nebraska Southern Miss Washington
Charlotte Nevada TCU Washington State
Florida Atlantic Northern Illinois Texas Western Kentucky
Fresno State Oklahoma State Texas State Wyoming
Houston Ole Miss Troy

Finally, many of the 1,463 ranked recruits have signed with FCS or Division II programs over the years. The most common non-FBS destinations are Villanova (24 recruits), Delaware (17), Duquesne (10) and Towson, IUP and Bucknell with 6 each.

Recruits by Position

Would it surprise you if I told you that linebacker is the most common position for ranked players from Pennsylvania? Well, I guess it probably shouldn’t, given the state’s history of producing pretty good ones. Of the 1,471 recruits listed (remember, we removed 8 guys who pursued other sports in college for the previous analyses), 172 – or 11.7% – were linebackers. The least common positions were long-snappers (3) and punters (5); center (13) had the fewest representatives from either offense or defense.

The full list:

Linebackers 172 11.7%
Offensive Tackles 146 9.9%
Wide Receivers 144 9.8%
Running Backs 122 8.3%
Defensive Ends 122 8.3%
Quarterbacks 113 7.7%
Guards 108 7.3%
Athletes 108 7.3%
Safeties 101 6.9%
Defensive Tackles 95 6.5%
Cornerbacks 95 6.5%
Tight Ends 91 6.2%
Fullbacks 18 1.2%
Kickers 15 1.0%
Centers 13 0.9%
Punters 5 0.3%
Long-Snappers 3 0.2%

Odds and Ends

  • Ranking and evaluating high school prospects is far from an exact science, so there are bound to be misses here and there. Remember, hindsight is always 20/20, so it’s easy to pick and choose misses after the fact. That being said, some of the guys I was surprised to see ranked so low coming out of high school are listed below. These are just a few of the ones I found notable – there are others to be discovered in the spreadsheet, I’m sure.
    • Way back in 2002, Larry Fitzgerald was ranked as the 11th-best player in Pennsylvania after spending a year at Valley Forge Military Academy. He turned out to be…pretty good.
    • The following year, Matt Ryan was considered the 23rd best prospect in the state.
    • Darrelle Revis – Before he became a 7-time Pro Bowler and 4-time First-Team All-Pro, Revis was considered just a three-star prospect coming out of Aliquippa. Perhaps more surprising was the fact that Revis ranked just 27th out of all Pennsylvania recruits in the class of 2004 despite a heralded high school career for a football power. Nationally, he was considered just the 42nd best cornerback recruit in his class.
    • Sean Lee – A year after Revis’ class, Lee placed 28th among all Pennsylvania recruits in 2005. Despite an injury-riddled career, Lee has been among the better linebackers in football when healthy. The 2005 class also had several other notable omissions from its statewide top-ten: Steve Slaton (15th), LaRod Stephens-Howling (27th), Daryll Clark (32nd), Tommie Campbell (41st) and Pat McAfee (47th – although that’s not a bad ranking for a kicker/punter).
    • Vincent Rey – While not truly a Pennsylvania recruit, Rey is one of the lowest-ranked players to have a substantial NFL career. Originally from New York, Rey played as a post-graduate at Mercersburg Academy, which placed him in the Pennsylvania class of 2006. He was ranked 57th overall in the state that year. Rey went on to Duke and then played nine years for the Cincinnati Bengals.
    • The Nassib Brothers – Ryan was rated as the 62nd-best player in the class of 2008; Carl wasn’t ranked at all in the class of 2011. Ryan went on to a strong career as a quarterback at Syracuse and played as a backup for two years in the NFL after being a fourth-round pick. Carl became a consensus All-America defensive end at Penn State who won the Lombardi Award in 2015. After being selected in the third round of the 2016 draft, he has accumulated 18 sacks in four NFL seasons.
    • The 2009 Class had several notable players receive low rankings: Jordan Hill (36th), Devin Street (37th), Bernard Pierce (47th), Justin Pugh (49th) and Brandon McManus (66th).
    • Although it’s still too early to tell for many guys, the rankings seem to have fewer big misses over the past six to eight years. Perhaps 247Sports’ evaluation system is better than the one Scout used (because all of the pre-2010 rankings shown on 247Sports are the old Scout ones, more or less).
  • There was one strange case I found during my research and it led to the only time in which I chose to omit a player from the rankings. In the class of 2014, Marcus Johnson, a wide receiver from University Prep, was ranked as the top player in the state and as a four-star prospect. When I investigated the “N/A” under where his college choice should have been listed, I found that Johnson spent his freshman year at Thiel before transferring to Slippery Rock. Johnson was a very good player who had a terrific career at Slippery Rock, but I found it difficult to believe that a player whose recruiting profile said he was the 99th best prospect in America went to a Division III school after high school. Additionally, the fact that Johnson’s 247Sports profile had a composite ranking but no individual ranking provided by 247Sports was strange for a guy with such a high rating. In the end, I came to the conclusion that Johnson’s profile or information was somehow confused with another athlete’s or had other errors, so I chose to remove him from the data I collected. However, he was clearly still a very good football player and I wanted to describe his story here.
  • I discussed the prevalence of five-star recruits earlier, but here is the data showing how many players from Pennsylvania since 2000 earned each star rating. The percent column shows the share of that rating out of all 1,471 ranked players:
    • 5-Stars 22 1.5%
      4-Stars 170 11.6%
      3-Stars 672 45.7%
      2-Stars 582 39.6%
      1-Stars 25 1.7%
    • One-star athletes were only recognized from 2014-2016 in this dataset, which helps to explain the low number of them overall.
    • Over the past 21 recruiting classes, about 13% of ranked recruits earned four or five stars. Keep in mind that ranked recruits constitute just a sliver of the players statewide who will end up playing college football at some level. If all players statewide were ranked, that percentage would be much, much lower.

It’s easy to see why recruiting rankings have such a passionate (rabid?) following. Everyone wants their college team to do well and it’s exciting to hear an expert say that the incoming crop of players is outstanding. Family, friends, teammates, coaches and community members love seeing their guy highly ranked and given the recognition he worked for. And, let’s be honest – there are many among us who like the entire process because it “proves” that (insert hated rival) is cheating. But beyond that, it’s clear that these rankings hold some value. There’s plenty of analysis out there saying that recruiting rankings do matter. I don’t disagree with any of that; following it closely is just not my cup of tea. But it sure can make the basis for some great discussions and stories, and I’m definitely here for that.

A Groundhog Day Appreciation Post

I took Meteorology 003 at Penn State as an undergrad for a science credit, so I’m essentially an expert on all things weather. Just don’t ask me to prove that. Now, I spent quite a few Thursdays at the Darkhorse (RIP), so those Friday morning lectures don’t stick in my memory as well as they should. But I’m almost certain that they didn’t say anything about shadows or small rodents, so I’m a bit skeptical of the whole Groundhog Day thing. But it’s also a great piece of Pennsylvania culture and it’s fun to revel in all of its weirdness, so let’s get started.

Three Notable Punxsutawney Chucks Football Players

Lloyd Jordan

Lloyd Jordan. Photo from College Football Hall of Fame.

A College Football Hall of Famer, Jordan was a player, coach, athletic director and conference commissioner. I’ve included him without knowing for certain whether he played high school football; his brief biography in the Punxsutawney Sports Hall of Fame only mentions a high school basketball career. He won 100 of his 175 games as a head coach at both Amherst and Harvard before becoming the commissioner of the Southern Conference from 1960-1973.

John Mizerock

Tue, Nov 16, 1976 – Page 18 · The Indiana Gazette (Indiana, Pennsylvania) · Newspapers.com
Mizerock, commonly called “Sarge” while an athlete at Punxsutawney, made his name as a Major League Baseball player and long-time coach. He also served as the manager of the Kansas City Royals in 2002. But Mizerock was also an outstanding football and basketball player for the Chucks. In 1978, he was named a second-team all-state defensive back by the Associated Press and finished his career as a quarterback with more than 2,500 passing yards and 1,000 rushing yards.

Devin Mesoraco

Wed, Dec 3, 2003 – Page 54 · Indiana Gazette (Indiana, Pennsylvania) · Newspapers.com
Picked 15th overall by the Cincinnati Reds in the 2007 Major League draft, Mesoraco (like Mizerock) achieved his greatest success as a catcher. Named to the 2014 National League All-Star Team, Mesoraco saw his career hampered by injuries by the time he turned 30. At Punxsutawney, Mesoraco ran for 345 yards as a freshman in 2003 while also starting at safety and handling punting duties. After playing football again as a sophomore, he gave up the sport to concentrate on baseball.

The Legend of Earle Mundell

Football in the twenty-first century means (among other things) becoming increasingly numb to astronomical offensive statistics. A quarterback surpassing 300 yards in a game? Commonplace. Teams having multiple 1,000-yard backs? Nice, but not nearly unheard of. A running back going for two-hundred plus? Buddy, our great state has seen a guy rush for well over a third of a mile.

Wide-open offensive systems, hurry-up approaches and teams playing up to 15 or 16 games in a season have warped our sense of numerical significance and seriously upped the ante for any athlete hoping to blow fans away with statistics. Even so, there are certain thresholds that still hold meaning. We could debate which milestones are still important or not, but most people would agree that rushing for 2,000 yards in a season is one of them. In 2019, only eight players statewide reached this mark, and only one (Northern’s Kyle Swartz) played fewer than 12 games.

If I told you a player once ran for 2,455 yards in a season, you’d likely be impressed; after all, only Ben Jackson of West Greene and Lenny Kelley of Dallas surpassed that total this past season. You may be more impressed to learn that this player did so in just 10 games, beating Swartz’s superlative 237.7 yards-per-game average from 2019.

But what if I told you this player did so in 1947, when everyone played both ways on grass fields and without facemasks? That he did so for a high school that no longer exists? That he played against opponents determined to knock him out of the game? And that he stood just 5-foot-4 and weighed 147 pounds? This is the story of Earle Mundell, a tiny back from Ambler High School with blazing speed that led him to additional fame on the track. A player who ran for more yards than anyone in Pennsylvania history up to that point, yet whose name has largely faded into history.


Sun, Oct 16, 1949 – 28 · Sunday News (Lancaster, Pennsylvania) · Newspapers.com

Mundell – whose name was often misspelled in print as “Earl” – would go on to be the smallest man on the 1950 Penn State football roster. He played for the Nittany Lions from 1949-1951 and was recognized as one of – if not the – fastest players on the team. As a high school senior, Mundell could run 50 yards in 5.5 seconds, roughly equivalent to a 4.4 forty yard dash.

Mundell’s legend was born in Ambler, which today is part of the Wissahickon School District. In 1955, eight years after he had last played high school football, the Delaware County Daily Times described him this way:

A scatback, Mundell was very deceptive and could stop on a dime while travelling (sic) at top speed. He was recalled as having tremendous speed and at times would reverse his field three and four times while on his way to a touchdown.

At the end of the season, Mundell became the first player in Bux-Mont Conference history to be named to the all-district team. During this era, Ambler won 33 games in a row, matching the number of touchdowns Mundell scored in 1947. He also earned a player-of-the-week award from the Maxwell Club, receiving high praise from then-Eagles owner Bert Bell at the ceremony. Following his final game, Mundell had scored 311 career points, which at the time was considered to be a national record. He also kicked and served as Ambler’s primary passer (remember, this is in the days of the single-wing).

Unfortunately, game-by-game recaps of Mundell’s terrific senior season have been difficult to come by online. Against Springfield (Montco), he had 31 carries for 243 yards and both touchdowns in a 12-0 win. Sadly, this is one of the few examples of game stories giving detailed statistics for Mundell’s exploits. Boxscores in the 1940s were basic at best and many newspapers only published statistics for scoring, not yardage totals. Many games were recapped with a simple blurb that gave only sparse descriptions of what had happened:

Mundell was a truly dominant force in suburban Philadelphia football. While he saw action at Penn State, he never shone as brilliantly as he did at Ambler. Some newspaper articles in the early 1950s asserted that Mundell’s lack of overwhelming success in college was due to his small stature. The fact that the game inflicted a punishing physical toll on him came up in more than one clipping that I found. While it is true that Mundell lacked ideal size to put up with the rough nature of football, one local journalist named Jim Hackett proposed that he took a beating because opponents were aiming to knock him out of the game. This tactic, while frowned upon by some, has always been a part of the game of football. The game in question, a 50-6 Ambler win over Jenkintown, had led some fans to claim that Ambler coach Johnny Meyer had run up the score. However, Hackett also alluded to another reason why Mundell had to withstand such rough play by his opponents:

“…For in the first quarter, Earl (sic) Mundell, the Black Knight of the Bux-Mont Conference was batted ruefully to the ground, immobilized… A crescendo of cheers shook the Jenkintown rooting section, they had ‘Got Mundell’…

“…as long as other teams insist on beating down a boy because he is great – or horrors, because he is Negro – Johnny Meyers will run up the markers for he has a right to do so…”

At another point in the season, Hackett described Springfield taking a similar approach when it came to roughing up Mundell:

“Another buddy reports that never in high school football has he seen a boy take the pounding Earl (sic) “Jinks” Mundell absorbed from Springfield on Saturday. Fists were flying into the lithe Trojan’s face on every play. His lips were swollen, his nose was gashed, his eyes were pinpoints when the game was over… But the kid showed [Springfield coach] Gockley his ability, his sheer guts, that all the rough tactics employed by a coach who has little respect for decency in sport – other than winning – could not stop him […] Futhermore, the hardened observer says he found himself leaping into the air as Mundell went on to score – not because Ambler won, but because this run was in direct repudiation of unsportsmanlike, rough football.”

Playing football as a black man in 1947 – the same year Jackie Robinson broke baseball’s color barrier – was exceptionally difficult. Even if you were given the opportunity to see the field, you were almost certain to face extremely physical play from your opponents that could easily cross the line into physical attacks. And while Mundell had the chance to attend a major university to play football, most college teams in the 1940s had very few black players on their rosters. Of course, for every school south of the Mason-Dixon Line during this era, the number of black players on college football teams was exactly zero. Northern teams often weren’t much more diverse. During his senior year of high school, Mundell was given a scholarship to Penn and, had he attended, would have been the first black athlete in the school’s history. And nearly every news article written about his athletic achievements referenced his race, sometimes going so far as to call him “The Black Knight.” All of this is not to assume that players from Jenkintown and Springfield were aggressive with Mundell solely because of his race, but it does serve as a chance to think about how discrimination played a role in the game as a whole during the time before the Civil Rights Era.

Mundell went on to graduate from Penn State and then earn a graduate degree from Xavier. He spent his career in education at schools in Ohio, serving as a teacher, a principal and a superintendent. He died in 2017 at the age of 87.


Legends are born by extraordinary performances in difficult circumstances, but they remain legends because of the haze and lack of clarity surrounding them. If we knew every single detail about Mundell’s season or had film of it, it would lose some of this luster. Today, we can watch games live from anywhere and endlessly review highlights; the impact technology has had on football is undeniable and overwhelmingly positive. Even so, there’s something alluring about the unknown, especially when our present world feels as if nothing is left undocumented. Reading seventy-year-old game recaps allows us to imagine how awesome Earle Mundell must have been, twisting and weaving his way around and through bewildered (and sometimes hostile) defenses. As nice as film is, I think I prefer it that way.

Pennsylvania High School Alumni Coaching FBS Programs

Last week, I took a look at Pennsylvania high school graduates who have led NFL teams as head coaches. This week’s post will focus on those who currently serve as head coaches in the NCAA, specifically at the FBS level. In stark contrast to the 28% of NFL jobs held by Pennsylvanians, only three of the 130 FBS positions (or 2.3%) belong to Keystone State grads. Those three coaches are James Franklin (Neshaminy → Penn State), Kirk Ferentz (Upper St. Clair → Iowa) and Randy Edsall (Susquehannock → UConn).

jfranklinnesh
James Franklin as a quarterback at Neshaminy. Image from PennLive.com: https://www.pennlive.com/pennstatefootball/2016/12/how_james_franklins_playing_pa.html

Here’s a clipping of Edsall’s high school days from 1975. Unfortunately, I wasn’t able to find a picture of Ferentz playing for Upper St. Clair’s football team. However, I did come across an unexpected article that mentions him playing hockey and scoring a goal against the old Armstrong High School in 1973.

As of the end of the 2019 season, Franklin (including his time at Vanderbilt) holds a career record of 80-38 (.678). In 21 years at Iowa (plus three at Maine), Ferentz has gone 174-125 (.582). Edsall, who has coached a pair of stints at UConn and one at Maryland, is 98-127 (.436).

We could probably spend a lot of time discussing why there is such a disparity between the number of Pennsylvanians serving as coaches at football’s two highest levels, but I think it’s likely just a statistical blip, if anything. I can’t think of many logical reasons why the NFL has three times as many coaches from our high schools as the FBS despite having a quarter as many teams, so I think it’s just an oddity without a real explanation or reason as to why it exists. Perhaps you could follow the line of thinking that Pennsylvania produces a lot of high-quality coaches and they view coaching in the NFL as the ultimate goal, leading many of them to take the professional route. I’m not certain that I’m sold on that theory, though.

A more wide-ranging post on Pennsylvania grads coaching at major college programs throughout history will be coming at a later time. Instead, I wanted to take time to briefly point out some trends in FBS coaching backgrounds as they stand today, now that Hawaii’s vacancy has been filled by Todd Graham and his Garth Brooks-style headset microphone.

  • Pennsylvania’s three current head coaches are tied for 12th among all states. The other states with three are Wisconsin, Utah, New Hampshire, Kansas and Arkansas. When comparing the historical clout of high school football in each of these states, it becomes more clear how low Pennsylvania’s number currently sits as opposed to what one may expect.
  • The state that can claim the most graduates as FBS head coaches? Ohio, with 13 (or exactly 10 percent of all coaches at that level). California (11) is second and Texas (10) is third.
  • Ten states do not have a current representative at the FBS level. These fall into two camps: the not-surprising and the fairly-surprising, at least to me. Vermont, Rhode Island, North Dakota, Maine, Delaware, Nevada and Alaska? Sure, those make sense. But Maryland, Michigan and (especially) Virginia? I don’t think I would’ve guessed that those three states would’ve been skunked by this survey.
  • Another surprise for me is the fact that the three teams tied for 8th are Georgia (not shocking) along with West Virginia and Indiana (more shocking). West (enter your chosen expletive) Virginia has some pretty good firepower, too, with a roster of Nick Saban, Jimbo Fisher and the solid but lesser known Doc Holliday joining newcomer Shawn Clark of Appalachian State. Indiana can’t match that lineup, but Kevin Sumlin, Tom Allen, Thomas Hammock and Mike Neu still represent more Hoosiers than I would’ve guessed.
  • The full table can be seen below:
BY STATE
OH 13
CA 11
TX 10
FL 8
OK 7
IL 6
TN 5
AL 5
WV 4
IN 4
GA 4
WI 3
UT 3
PA 3
NH 3
KS 3
AR 3
SD 2
SC 2
OR 2
NJ 2
NE 2
NC 2
MS 2
MN 2
LA 2
KY 2
IA 2
WY 1
WA 1
NY 1
NM 1
MT 1
MO 1
MA 1
ID 1
HI 1
DC 1
CT 1
CO 1
AZ 1
VT 0
VA 0
RI 0
NV 0
ND 0
MI 0
ME 0
MD 0
DE 0
AK 0

Take a look at these and feel free to drop any other observations in the comments.

Pennsylvania High School Alums Coaching in the NFL

Even though it’s the first month of the high school football off-season, plenty has happened in January in the professional ranks to keep things interesting from a Pennsylvania high school football perspective. In the past ten days, four NFL franchises hired coaches who played their scholastic football in the Keystone State: Mike McCarthy (Dallas, from the now-closed Bishop Boyle HS in Homestead), Matt Ruhle (Carolina, State College), Joe Judge (Giants, Lansdale Catholic) and Kevin Stefanski (Cleveland, St. Joe’s Prep).

When adding these four new hires to the five existing Pennsylvania high school grads holding head coaching positions (Sean McDermott, Matt Nagy, Frank Reich, Bruce Arians and Vic Fangio), just over 28 percent of the NFL is led by guys from our state. I wanted to take a look to see how the size of the upcoming 2020 crop stacked up against past years in terms of Pennsylvanians holding NFL head coaching positions. As I had expected, no previous year can match the nine head coaches that will roam professional sidelines next fall. However, that doesn’t mean some years didn’t come close or that I didn’t find plenty of interesting names, stories, and numbers along the way.

To do this research, I started where everyone must when exploring the history of professional football: pro-football-reference.com. Knowing that PFR had a listing of every NFL coach throughout the history of the league, I went through the biographical information of each of the 500 coaches listed to sift out the ones who attended high school in our state. In the end, I found 64 NFL head coaches (counting the recent hires) who played scholastic football here, or nearly 13 percent of all head coaches in the league’s history. Additionally, PFR lists five more coaches who were born in Pennsylvania but went to high school in another state; the information throughout the rest of this post excludes these five coaches. Apologies to Mike Holovak, Dick Nolan, Jim Trimble, Joe Stydahar and Hank Bullough, but I wanted this post to focus on those coaches who attended high school here.

Image result for mike mccarthy cowboys shirt
Bishop Boyle High School closed in 1984 because school administrators predicted Mike McCarthy would wear a shirt this ugly more than 35 years later.

Overview

To begin, let’s take a look at the cumulative statistics of the 64 coaches in question:

GAMES 3878
WINS 1904
LOSSES 1910
TIES 64
WIN % 0.499

Barring a rash of firings during next season, our nine alums will bring the total number of games coached by Pennsylvania high school grads past 4,000 all-time. Surpassing the 2,000 win barrier could happen in the 2021 season, and with any luck the current group will help get the state’s overall winning percentage over the .500 mark.

A few notes on some of the coaches on the list:

  • Individually, Marty Schottenheimer’s 200 wins lead all Pennsylvania natives (and rank 8th in NFL history). Six others have at least 100 wins. Chuck Knox leads in both games coached (334) and losses (147); his 186 wins are second only to Schottenheimer.
  • Bill Cowher, McCarthy and Mike Ditka have won the state’s three Super Bowls.
  • I haven’t had the chance to run the numbers to be sure of this, but I would guess that Fort Cherry High School is one of (if not the) only high school in America with two graduates holding at least 100 career NFL wins (Schottenheimer and Marvin Lewis).
  • Aldo Donelli, a Bridgeville High grad who coached both the Steelers and the then-Cleveland Rams for a year apiece, made his name in a different kind of football altogether. He played soccer for the US Men’s National Team in the 1934 World Cup and is enshrined in the National Soccer Hall of Fame.
  • Yeadon’s John Rauch graduated from the University of Georgia in 1948 as the NCAA’s all-time leader in career passing yards. He later coached the Oakland Raiders but resigned due to frustration over Al Davis’ meddling in the team. Rauch went on to coach the Bills for two years; Davis replaced him with John Madden.
  • The other Rauch on the list, Dick, was the head coach of the 1925 Pottsville Maroons, a team that claimed the NFL championship but later had it nullified because of an archaic territorial rule after playing an exhibition game on another team’s geographic footprint.
  • Hinkey Haines coached just one year in the NFL and earned more renown for his achievements as both a football and baseball player. Haines was a member of both a World Series champion (the 1923 Yankees) and an NFL champion (the 1927 Giants).
  • Three different coaches finished their careers with exactly zero wins, but two of them (Hal Hunter and Dick Modzelewski) only coached one game. The other? Monaca’s John Karcis, who, as a 5’9, 223 pound fullback, was appropriately nicknamed “Bull.” Karcis had a solid nine-year playing career and was named second-team All-Pro in 1937. His coaching career was less successful but remarkable in at least one way: he made the jump directly from coaching high school to being an NFL head coach the following year. In 1940 and 1941, Karcis led Pitcairn High School (located outside of Pittsburgh) to records of 0-6-2 and 4-3-2, respectively. In 1942, Detroit Lions coach Bill Edwards was fired after an 0-3 start. Looking for a change in direction, the Lions hired Karcis from Pitcairn to salvage the season. It didn’t work. Detroit lost its remaining eight games (getting outscored 208-31) and finished 0-11. Karcis, now with a career record of 0-8, would never lead an NFL team again. To be fair, 1942 was the first season where the NFL began to see players enlist in the World War II effort, leaving many teams shorthanded and forced to play on with whatever ramshackle group they could throw together. In a few ways, Karcis’ career was doomed from the start. He was pulled directly from coaching teenagers to hard-fought wins over Plum and Trafford and thrown into a schedule featuring opponents like Sammy Baugh, Sid Luckman, Don Hutson and others. Karcis’ own roster was less star-studded than his opponents’, you could say. In 1942, the Lions failed to have a player surpass 300 yards rushing or 300 yards passing for the entire season. The team’s quarterback rating was – get ready – 8.2. Not 82. Eight-point-two over 11 games. I guess that’s what happens when you throw one touchdown and 33 interceptions over the course of a season. Anyway, I’d argue that Karcis’ coaching ability should not be looked down upon based on his fraction of a season with a subpar roster, especially considering the huge jump he made when going from high school to professional football.
  • Another Pennsylvania native whose career shouldn’t be measured by his struggles as a head coach is Bert Bell. A member of the inaugural class of the Pro Football Hall of Fame in 1963, Bell served 14 years as NFL commissioner, was a co-founder of the Philadelphia Eagles and was the driving force behind the creation of the NFL Draft. However, Bell’s six years as a head coach were far from inspiring. From 1936-1940, his Eagles teams went just 10-44-2. In late 1940, Bell arranged a bizarre flip-flop with Steelers president Art Rooney to essentially trade the entire Steelers roster for the Eagles’. Bell finished his coaching career after just two games with Pittsburgh the following fall, losing both. Bell isn’t remembered for his coaching career, though. His legacy is the fact that he built the NFL through the 1950s as it emerged from college football’s shadow, planting the seeds for the monolith we see today.

To see the entire list of coaches who played for Pennsylvania high schools, click here.

Image result for marty schottenheimer
A Pittsburgh-area guy coaching another Pittsburgh-area guy…for Kansas City.

The Years

Our group of nine coaches will represent the highest number of Pennsylvanians leading NFL franchises in a single year once the 2020 season rolls around. In fact, no other season has had more than seven such coaches. The record number coming this fall is perhaps more impressive when you consider that the 2007 season featured only two Pennsylvania high school graduates at head coach. Before that year, the last time the number fell that low was in 1981. And while the 1950s were an anomaly (zero Pennsylvanians were head coaches from 1952 to 1958), that period was the last time the NFL lacked representation from our state.

PA HS Grads Coaching in NFL by Year

The 2020 season is set up to potentially be a year where Pennsylvania grads begin to build an even stronger foothold in the professional coaching world. However, as things stand right now, the unquestioned golden years for our state ran from the early-1980s to the mid-2000s. Our state’s nine winningest coaches were all active during this time period, two of the alum’s three Super Bowls were won, and in 1984, 1992, 1993 and 1997 there were seven Pennsylvanians serving as NFL head coaches.

The Schools

Just over one-third of the schools that NFL coaches from Pennsylvania have called their alma mater are now closed. They include recent closures like Monaca and Peabody, historical powers like Harrisburg Tech and Harrisburg John Harris, and smaller, more obscure high schools like Girardville and Avalon. The defunct public schools on the list merged together to form many of the high school programs we would recognize today. With the exception of Monaca – which merged with Center in 2009 to form Central Valley – most of these mergers happened no later than the 1950s as the Commonwealth sought to decrease the number of districts statewide from more than 2,000 to about 500.

Five schools have had multiple graduates serve as NFL head coaches: Fort Cherry, Beaver Falls, Haverford School, Bellefonte Academy and St. Joseph’s Prep. From a geographic perspective, it shouldn’t be a surprise that most coaches came from areas concentrated around Philadelphia and, especially, Pittsburgh:

Because the public vs. private school debate remains a hot topic among high school football fans, I thought I’d check out those numbers, too. Nearly three-quarters of our NFL coach alums attended public schools and one-in-five were graduates of private schools. The remaining five percent attended schools that were publicly funded but would be called “non-boundary” schools today: Harrisburg Tech, Northeast Manual Training (Philadelphia) and perhaps the most extreme, controversial and famous example, the Carlisle Indian Industrial School.

Speaking of the Carlisle Indian School: I chose to include Jim Thorpe on this list, but not William “Lone Star” Dietz, another former NFL coach who attended the school. Thorpe, a native Oklahoman, first attended the famous Haskell Institute in Kansas but then made his way to Carlisle at the age of 16. After dropping out, he returned to the school at 19 to begin his college career, helping Carlisle and Pop Warner achieve national prominence in the early 1900s. Dietz, on the other hand, attended a school for Native Americans in Oklahoma and didn’t enroll at Carlisle until he was 25. For this reason, I chose to consider his time at Carlisle as consisting of collegiate years; the school educated Native Americans from a wide-range of ages, including those in their twenties. Additionally, Dietz likely wasn’t Native American at all – it is probable that he was a white man pretending to be one.

In the end, this exercise served as a clear reminder of the clout Pennsylvania holds in professional football. As the shift in football power at the high school and college levels continues to move southward, it is worth remembering how many legends of the game, both players and coaches, came from our state and impacted it in the professional ranks.

Accounts that Some Guy Likes to Follow on Twitter Pertaining to High School Football in Pennsylvania

This was a big year for PFH – I gained somewhere around 1,000 followers, which is pretty good for an idiot with a Twitter account. Thanks to all of you who have joined in and reached out. I’m in the early stages of revamping the blog you’re currently reading, primarily by pushing for consistent posts to cover the history of football in our great Commonwealth. I have plenty to write about (and I’ve already started), but I want to put out the Bat Signal for submissions, as well. If you’re interested in providing an article for this blog, just get in touch via Twitter (@pa_fb_history) or email (pafbhistory@gmail.com). The only stipulations are that your topic pertains to high school football history in Pennsylvania and that you take care to write it from an objective point of view.  That’s it.

The main thing I wanted to do in this post was to recognize just a few of the people who make the online community surrounding Pennsylvania high school football fun to be a part of (at least it is most of the time). Not that I didn’t think these people existed beforehand, but my eyes were opened in 2019 to the huge number of people who provide amazing coverage of high school football in our state. My aim here is not to mention everyone who has done a great job; that would take far too long and I would still miss people. But I wanted to highlight a few writers (and others) who have found a way to make the cesspool called Twitter enjoyable through their passion for the game they cover.

    • Sykotyk (@sykotyk): The D.B. Cooper of high school football – anonymous and fascinating (although I’m fairly certain he’s not the type to hijack an airplane). I wouldn’t know Sykotyk if I bumped into him at a 6-man football game in eastern Montana, but I do know that he: (a) Could tell me everything about both of those 6-man teams and (b) Would do so with an undying passion for scholastic football. The man is incredible. He logs thousands of miles, nearly one-hundred games and innumerable stats, pictures, details, anecdotes and other bits of knowledge each season. He’s my favorite follow on Twitter and should rank highly for anyone else who loves high school football. One last thing: while this can be really difficult to judge in some situations on social media, Sykotyk is clearly a solid guy. Follow him (just not literally unless you have access to lots and lots of gasoline).
    • Chris Masse (@docmasse): If it weren’t for Cheltenham’s shocking run to the 5A state title game, the biggest story in this year’s playoffs would have probably been the Cinderella run made by Jersey Shore. A team with little historical success played in a few instant-classic games (especially a 3OT win over Pottsville on Nov. 22) before falling to Dallas in the 4A semifinals. And during it all, Masse was there covering every second of it. Following a local team’s surprisingly deep run into a state tournament can lead some sportswriters to sound a lot like fanboys, but Masse avoided this trap while conveying the excitement and awe that followed a town’s once-in-a-generation-type team. Doc gets bonus points for his detailed reporting of statistics and milestones reached throughout the season.
    • PGH Sports History (@PGH_Sports_Date): Hey, those of us in the sports history niche need to stick together, right? PGHSH covers all sports in the Pittsburgh area, but it’s one of the most reliably awesome high school football history sites around. You may not be a Pirates/Penguins/Steelers/Pitt/etc. fan, but the account is worth its weight in gold for its coverage of both the WPIAL and City League’s histories. Looking for newspaper clippings from the City League’s only state championship? Here you go. Classic articles from the great Mike White? PGHSH has those, too.
    • Bob Greenburg (@BobGreenburg): Bob recently tweeted the number of years he’s been covering high school sports in District 10 and he’s been doing it two years longer than I’ve been alive. Don’t worry, Bob – I’m only 11. He’d likely be the first to tell you that he’s outspoken about issues in scholastic athletics. And I didn’t include him on the list because I always agree with him, because I don’t. But the fact that he’s one of my favorite follows despite not always agreeing with him speaks to the respect I have for his historical perspective. Bob also is the author of one of my must-read Twitter threads each week where he strings together interesting historical and statistical tidbits pertaining to that week’s games. Here’s to many more years of being the voice of D10.
    • Pennsylvania Football News (@PaFootballNews): I’d find it hard to believe that a Pennsylvania high school football fan isn’t following PFN. Billy Splain and his cast of thousands blanket the state each week to report on games from every nook and cranny of the Commonwealth. They also extensively promote the college recruiting side of things, which isn’t a primary interest of mine but is to many others (not to mention the players themselves). I also included this account for nostalgic reasons. This tiny, almost completely unknown blog that you’re reading right now wouldn’t exist if my dad – who has never been much of a reader – hadn’t bought a PFN Resource Guide many years ago. It may be the only book my dad has ever purchased and I’m not sure how much he ever read it. However, I do know that his son absolutely devoured it. The work begun in the 1990s as a printed newsletter by Rich Vetock and Tom Elling continues today as likely the most visible media outlet devoted to the sport in Pennsylvania. For those of you who weren’t around then, this is what PFN looked like around the time my household got the internet and well before social media existed. Unfortunately, the link is broken to the page listing teams with open dates, so you’re out of luck if you need to find an opponent for the 2000 season.
    • Others deserving mention are: Mike White (@mwhiteburgh), Tom Reisenweber (@ETNreisenweber), EasternPAFootball (@EPAFootball), WesternPAFootball.net (@WPAFootball), Mike Drago (@MDrago59), Jeff Reinhart (@JeffReinhart77), The Steelers n’at (@thesteelersnat), D9Sports.com (@D9Sports), WPIAL Football Zone (@AJWPIAL), Shayne Schafer (@shayne_schafer), & West Perry Football Stats (@wpfbstats).

Again, I’ve missed many, many awesome people who cover the game incredibly well. Apologies if you’re not listed; it just isn’t possible to mention everyone who helps to build this community around a game we all love. There is a comment section below – drop a shoutout to someone who isn’t listed here.